Scrum vs. PMP: every part you need to know
Being in control of a mission isn’t a stroll within the park.
With out the proper basis it could possibly really feel extra like strolling by means of a area filled with landmines. Whereas blind-folded.
Certification will help you acquire the data you want for the job, whereas additionally leading to a pleasant pay bump.
However between PMP and Scrum, which choice will more than likely assist your profession? Which coaching and mission administration certification do you have to select?
On this article, we’ll examine the PMP and Scrum certifications, their value, influence on wage, and the variations within the strategies themselves.
Scrum vs. PMP: Certification
In order for you a proper certification of your expertise as a mission administration skilled, you will have many various choices.
However the most well-liked is the Undertaking Administration Skilled (PMP) certification by the PMI institute.
There are over 1.037 million PMP licensed mission managers around the globe.
It’s most dear for corporations that use a extra conventional method to mission administration.
The PMP designation is essentially primarily based on the Undertaking Administration Physique of Data (PMBOK) methodology, which is commonly conflated with the Waterfall mannequin. (Extra on this later.)
If you wish to work for smaller, extra Agile corporations like groundbreaking startups, likelihood is a lot increased that they’re working with Scrum.
There are two predominant certifications for Scrum: the Licensed ScrumMaster (CSM) by Scrum Alliance, and Skilled Scrum Grasp (PSM) by Scrum.org.
(Picture Supply)
341,882 Scrum masters have some stage of the PSM certification.
Earlier than we go any additional, we should always level out that Scrum certification is not the identical as Agile certification.
Having the PSM or CSM certificates reveals you recognize Agile to some extent, as it’s essential to be acquainted with the overarching Agile ideas and values.
But it surely solely certifies you for one Agile framework — Scrum.
If you wish to seek the advice of corporations on Agile transformation, otherwise you need to work for a corporation that embraces a special framework, like SAFe, you’ll have to look into different certification choices, corresponding to turning into a Licensed Agile Coach. Learn this publish for extra on agile mission administration certification.
Alright, now that’s clear, let’s bounce again to Scrum vs PMP.
Impression on salaries and incomes energy
Within the US, the common mission supervisor’s wage is $66,137 per yr in accordance with Glassdoor.
The PMI’s official wage survey confirmed a a lot increased annual earnings. Respondents had a median wage of $116,000.
(Picture Supply)
And mission managers with PMP certification had a 22% increased wage, on common.
Based on Glassdoor, the common wage for the Scrum Grasp position is $97,319 within the US.
And, in accordance with the 2019 Scrum Grasp Tendencies report, 51% of respondents made $75,000 or extra per yr. Certification differentiates the highest earners.
(Picture Supply)
To sum up all these numbers:
- Each the PMP and Scrum certification seem to immediately influence incomes energy
- However, somebody with their PMP tends to make greater than somebody with Scrum certification
Price of certification
Taking the PMP examination to get licensed prices $550 (USD).
Coaching for the course can value as much as $3,000, however it’s also possible to self-study the ideas with the PgMP handbook or PMBOK information. These books value round $60 every.
Subsequent, let’s take a more in-depth take a look at what the Scrum certifications value.
The PSM1 certification take a look at prices $150, and official programs begin at round $500.
The CSM examination is usually solely administered as a part of a CSM course. A course can value anyplace from $595 to $1,500. The worth will depend on location, teacher, and whether or not the course is in-person or on-line.
Which is best; PMP or Scrum grasp?
The wage implications and prices of certification aren’t totally different sufficient to make one choice the clear winner. So it actually will depend on your profession targets and present expertise.
Do you need to work in an trade that focuses on PMBOK ideas? PMP is the best way to go.
Do you need to work as a part of small, Agile Scrum Groups in startups, tech, and different revolutionary corporations? It is best to turn out to be a licensed Scrum grasp.
Scrum vs. PMP: Methodology
Subsequent, let’s study what the precise mission administration methodology appears to be like like for every choice.
PMP is targeted on the PMBOK mannequin, so let’s begin there.
The PMBOK mannequin
Prior to now, individuals used to equal PMBOK with the top-down Waterfall method. It’s because it divides mission administration into 5 totally different phases or course of teams.
- Initiating
- Planning
- Executing
- Monitoring and controlling
- Closing
Nonetheless, PMBOK focuses on overarching ideas and doesn’t prescribe methodology.
Within the context of a single Dash or cycle in Agile or Scrum, you possibly can nonetheless apply lots of the PMBOK ideas — You’re simply doing the 5 phases per iteration as an alternative of as soon as per mission.
However, you’ll discover a lot of the PMBOK information is written to imagine you’re utilizing a top-down, pre-planned framework like Waterfall.
It additionally tends to emphasise a number of documentation, which is one thing Agile advises towards.
Scrum framework
The Scrum framework is designed particularly for the Agile methodology. As an alternative of making an attempt to determine how one can adapt PMBOK to work for Agile, Scrum lays out a transparent step-by-step answer.
Slightly than following 5 clearly outlined phases that occur as soon as throughout a mission, you divide bigger initiatives into smaller sprints, lasting 1–4 weeks.
There are nonetheless 5 recognizable phases inside every dash, however they go by totally different names:
- Pre-planning (or Backlog refinement)
- Planning (aka Dash planning)
- Working (Execution)
- Dash overview (or Product increment overview)
- Retrospective
To be taught extra in regards to the Scrum framework try our article on Find out how to run a Scrum dash.
What’s the distinction between PMP (PMBOK) and Agile?
Each PMBOK and Agile methodologies prescribe high-level ideas moderately than a concrete framework to information your method.
The largest distinction between PMBOK and Agile lies of their perspective towards change and stakeholder involvement.
PMBOK emphasizes construction and management — change is considered as a needed evil. Agile, however, embraces and encourages change.
In PMBOK, you primarily contain stakeholders throughout early-stage planning. However in Agile the collaboration continues all through all the mission.
Scrum vs. PMP: Generally the proper alternative is each
Sadly, like with most issues on this world, there’s no lower and dry proper reply.
For some corporations, Scrum can be an apparent alternative, whereas others will do higher with PMBOK.
For a lot of, the only option is commonly to implement each methodologies in numerous areas.
Likewise, it’s possible you’ll resolve to acquire each certifications over time.
PMBOK for acquainted or ongoing initiatives
If you recognize a mission in and out, you don’t want a revolutionary method.
Would an company delivering copy or artistic to a gentle consumer for the one hundredth time see clear advantages from making a Scrum group? In all probability not.
For predictable, acquainted initiatives, utilizing PMBOK ideas inside your current group construction might be your greatest wager.
PMBOK’s Work Breakdown Construction (WBS) is an efficient start line.
You need to use our Undertaking WBS template to handle human sources extra effectively, and maintain initiatives working in accordance with schedule.
Scrum for brand new and unpredictable initiatives
However working throughout the confines of a conventional workflow isn’t all the time going to be the best choice.
For brand new initiatives, like creating a brand new product concentrating on a brand new vertical, the Scrum framework is ideal.
An excellent place to start out is to discover a logical product proprietor. They could possibly be a key buyer or somebody who has a deep understanding of your clients.
For instance, for those who’re growing proposal software program for salespeople, your inside gross sales supervisor could possibly be an excellent product proprietor in Scrum.
The product imaginative and prescient and product backlog are user-focused, not technical or feature-focused. So a non-technical individual can nonetheless spotlight consumer tales (options from the consumer’s perspective).
This may show you how to gauge the scope of the mission, and set up an entire Scrum group with all the talents needed to finish it.
An Agile mission method enables you to hit the bottom working, and adapt alongside the market and buyer base.
Even with out expertise in a market, you possibly can create an revolutionary product that clients need.
Take a look at our complete information to the Scrum methodology or use our Scrum planning template to leap proper in.
Conclusion
Turning into licensed in Scrum or PMBOK are each nice profession strikes relying in your scenario.
All of it comes right down to the place you need to be sooner or later.
monday.com’s templates make it simple to check every mannequin of mission administration in your present firm.
For instance, you can begin with our WBS template, and see if it improves your workflow.
